Research Findings
Game and tools
Game
RDR2 PC, build 1.0.1491.50 (Steam build 13773296).
Archives
Every archive in the install was opened: about 494,000 files.
Map files
13,595 .ymap files placing 413,759 objects, and 2,498 .ytyp archetype files.
Compiled scripts
The game ships its story scripts in one encrypted archive, script_rel.rpf (113 MB). No public tool opens it, so the script search below uses community decompiles and the game's live memory.
CodeX 0.29 libraries
Read RDR2's archives: models, map files, archetypes, textures and text. We called its DLLs from our own command-line scanner instead of using the app.
Our scanner (C#, .NET 8)
Lists and dumps archive files, exports textures and meshes, and scans every model for mark-like geometry.
Decompiled scripts
Community decompiles of the game's scripts for builds 1311.12, 1355, 1436 and 1491.50.
Python
numpy renderer for the marks, minimap calibration, line-casting, hour-mask decoding and searches over the object index.
RedLua + ScriptHookRDR2
Runs our Lua lab inside the game: overlay, teleports, clock control, scripted shots, memory reads, map pins.
Cheat Engine 7.7
Byte-pattern scans of the running game's memory and write watches on the feather objects.
OpenIV
Read-only cross-checks of archive contents.
Script search
Script sets
| Repository | Game build | Scripts |
|---|---|---|
| Halen84/RDR3-Decompiled-Scripts | 1491.50 (same as the game) | 1,639 story |
| kepmehz/RDR3-Decompiled-Scripts | 1436 | 1,638 story |
| kepmehz/RDR3-Decompiled-Scripts | 1355 | 1,639 story |
| JayKoZa/RDR2-Decompiled-Scripts | 1311.12 | 1,639 story + 558 online |
| pyouneetm/RDR2-Decompiled-Scripts | 1311.12 | Same files as JayKoZa |
What we searched for
Each name as text, and its hash (joaat) as hex, signed decimal and unsigned decimal, in every .c file of all five sets. We also searched for any request to load the clue map files (REQUEST_IMAP).
| Web | Feather | Feather hash | Web mesh | Web hash |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| sd05 Heartland Overflow | spiderdream05x | 0x5B04332C | cablemesh19309_hvlit001 | 0x2195E214 |
| sd06 Scarlett Meadows | spiderdream06x | 0xC004FE14 | cablemesh217268_hvlit001 | 0x709C247F |
| sd03 Cornwall Kerosene & Tar | spiderdream03x | 0x79B3E083 | cablemesh11342_hvlit001 | 0xAA6249CB |
| sd08 Saint Denis | spiderdream08x | 0xA942CEA4 | cablemesh217187_hvlit001 | 0x0BCD910A |
| sd04 Emerald Station | spiderdream04x | 0x8448EDE9 | cablemesh19339_hvlit001 | 0x03FB5DDA |
| sd07 Southfield Flats | spiderdream07x | 0x9945B676 | cablemesh217239_hvlit001 | 0x796A1E04 |
| sd01 Ringneck Creek (lower) | spiderdream01x | 0xD6E7944D | cablemesh19279_hvlit001 | 0xE3CB9D96 |
| sd02 Heartland Oil Fields (upper) | spiderdream02x | 0x0EDF0543 | cablemesh19374_hvlit001 | 0x9149E067 |
| Name | What it is | Hash |
|---|---|---|
| jklm_7_10_scratchin | Spider glyph object | 0x47BAD66F |
| nbx_wall_wood_broken01_abspiderlegs_al | Spider glyph texture | - |
| cablemesh277747_hvlit001 | Butcher Creek pentagram | - |
| cablemesh87397_thvy001, 87399_thvy001, 87405_hvlit001, 87455_hvlit001 | Center web | - |
| jklm_11_14_rds_me2, jklm_11_14_rds_me3, me1 | Pole carvings (me1 does not exist) | - |
Coordinates
Every x, y, z number triple in the 1436 and 1491.50 sets was compared against these sites, with a 100 m radius: sd01 to sd08, center web, pentagram, Butcher Creek outhouses, Fort Brennand tally 6, Fort Brennand tally 7, Fort Wallace, me2, me3.
Live memory search
With the game running, Cheat Engine scanned all of its memory for the 22 hashes above: 8 feathers, 13 web meshes (8 webs, the pentagram and the 4 center-web meshes) and the glyph. A second scan by our lab looked for every feather and web identifier (model IDs, names, placement IDs, positions, effect IDs) at Cornwall, once outside the 03:00 hour and once inside it.
We also read all 116 audio configuration files (.rel). None contains a feather or web hash.
Map data
- Each archetype can carry timeFlags, a 24-bit mask with one bit per hour (bit 24 lets it switch while on screen). 2,167 archetypes in the game have a mask.
- Exactly 21 are visible for a single hour, and all 21 are mystery pieces: the 8 webs, the 8 feathers, the pentagram (04:00, with bit 24 set) and the 4 center-web meshes (01:00).
- No other flag, script hook or load condition is attached to them. The hour mask is the only gate.
- We compared every map-file field of the 8 feathers and 8 webs side by side: names, IDs, hour masks, draw distances, effects. They differ only in hour, position, draw distance and the pack they sit in.
- Draw distances: feathers 37 m (sd08 31 m), webs 32 m, pentagram 33 m, center web 146 m.
- All 8 feathers are copies of the dreamcatcher model p_indiandream02x and carry the same particle effect (0xC5876498, the normal feather burst). 5 are black and 3 red, depending on the pack.
- The pack jklm_7_10 (Cornwall) holds the glyph, the Cornwall web, the pentagram (2 km outside the pack's area) and the center web (1 km outside).
- me1 does not exist anywhere in the files, not even as a hash.
Whole-game mark scan
All 113,468 models in the game were scanned for carvings. The known marks come in three styles: cut lines hidden with vertex transparency (tallies 1 to 5, LJ & SM), polygons tinted black through the colour palette (tallies 6 and 7, the pictograms) and painted marks.
Feather experiments
Shooting
Each feather was shot with scripted bullets (250 damage each) and by hand (about 33 per hit), with quiet control windows before and after, and decoy shots at nearby props. These fields of the feather object changed on a hit:
| Offset | Change |
|---|---|
| +0x40 to +0x6C | Rotation matrix (the feather tips over) |
| +0x130 to +0x138 | Position (it falls about 7.5 m) |
| +0x18C | Holds 1000, the maximum health |
| +0x1B0 | Flags go from 12 to 396 |
| +0x330 to +0x360 | A new pointer appears (physics) |
| +0x390 | Bit 0x40 is set |
Hour sweep
At sd06 (hour 2) the clock was held at each time below. Each time we teleported 800 m away and back so the area reloaded, then listed the feather objects that existed.
| Clock | sd06 feather |
|---|---|
| 01:30 | Created, visible |
| 02:30 | Re-created, visible |
| 03:30 | Re-created, visible |
| 03:44 | Re-created, visible |
| 05:30 | Re-created, visible |
| 12:30 | Re-created, visible |
Other checks
- The heart carved under Bacchus Bridge (538.1, 1738.6, 174.0): checked in game, nothing there.
- The two question marks in the Grizzlies terrain (tiles i_12__lod_1_1_-3 and i_12__hd_0_0_3) are the edges of rock and scree texture patches. The patches follow the terrain's erosion blend map i_12_c. Nothing is placed within 120 m and no script names the tiles.
- Spawn points within 60 m of every clue site are herbs, animals, buried treasure and town people. None starts a script at night.
- No object in the game is hidden inside a breakable prop at the clue sites, the forts or the poles.
- Eagle Flies' grave is a mission location loaded by a script flag. The Two Crows graffiti phrases are cheat codes. The carved tree arrows lead to the Bennett grave. There is no Giant's Cave.
- The clock that stops near camp in chapter 2 is part of a camp mission.